Challenging an Arbitration Award

Arbitration is often a better choice for the parties than litigation in court, because arbitration is often completed more quickly and with less legal expenses than a lawsuit in court.  The downside for the party that loses the arbitration is that there are very few grounds to challenge an arbitrator’s decision.  Furthermore, a complaint to vacate an arbitration award must be filed in court soon after the date of the arbitration award, or the right to challenge the award is forever waived.

Under the Michigan Court Rules, there are only four grounds to vacate an arbitration award.  These focus on the fairness of the proceeding, rather than whether the arbitrator’s decision was correct or incorrect.  The arbitrator can be set aide only if:

(1)  The award was procured by corruption, fraud or other undue means;

(2)  There was evident partiality by an arbitrator appointed as a neutral, corruption of an arbitrator, or misconduct prejudicing a party’s rights;

(3)  The arbitrator exceed his or her powers; or

(4)  The arbitrator refused to postpone the hearing on a showing of sufficient cause, refused to hear evidence material to the controversy, or otherwise conduct the hearing to prejudice substantially a party’s rights.

If you are dissatisfied with the outcome of an arbitration, it is also very important to act promptly.  There is a very short time period to file a complaint in court to vacate an arbitration award.  Depending on the grounds for challenging the arbitration award, the complaint must be filed within 21 days or 91 days after the date of the arbitration award.  If the complaint is not timely filed, it is too late to challenge the arbitration award later.

This article was written by Mark S. Demorest, Managing Member of Demorest Law Firm